A colleague mentions a difficult review. You know the reviewer. You’ve seen that sort of comment before. Halfway through explaining how you would respond, you notice your colleague still hasn’t said what happened.
Try an ordinary question first: “Do you want to talk it through, or would it help to come up with a reply?” Ask it in your own words. You’re offering a choice, not asking them to produce a perfect brief while they’re still upset.

When they want a listener
Invite the scene. “Which part has stayed with you?” Then use their answer to check your understanding: “You expected feedback on the draft, and instead the meeting turned into a discussion about your role. Have I got that right?” Leave space for them to tell you you’ve missed the important bit.
Listening doesn’t mean you have to agree with every interpretation. You can recognize the experience without deciding what the reviewer intended: “That sounds like a difficult surprise.” If you’re unsure, ask another small question instead of filling in the motive yourself.
Resist recruiting yourself into the dispute. Promising to speak to the reviewer can create a second problem if your colleague never wanted the conversation to leave the room. Ask before sharing their account or taking action on their behalf.
When they ask for an idea
Ask what they want the reply to achieve. Reopening the design decision is different from finding out why the agenda changed. Offer one possible first sentence and let them edit it out loud:
I came prepared to discuss the draft. Can we set aside ten minutes to talk about the role question separately?
If they wince at your wording, that’s information. Ask which part sounds unlike them. A sentence they would actually send is worth more than three polished paragraphs they quietly delete. You can also ask what they’ve tried already; they may have ruled out your first suggestion for a good reason.
When you don’t know enough to advise, say so. “I don’t know the policy here, but we could find the right person to ask” is more useful than inventing certainty. They still get to decide what to do next.
When they aren’t sure
“I don’t know” is a valid answer to the opening question. You can begin by listening and check in later: “Would it be useful to think about options now, or would you rather keep talking?” People can change their minds halfway through a conversation.
The choice isn’t always just listening or advice. They might want help preparing for a conversation, a distraction, or someone to sit with them while they decide. Offer a little time and ask what would help; don’t force their answer into your two original options.
“That review was rough.”
You ask, “Want to talk it through, or would it help to figure out what to say?” Let their answer set the pace.
“I just want to tell someone.”
- You
- “I’m listening. What happened?”
- Colleague
- “I went in with a draft and came out wondering whether my job had changed.”
- You
- “That’s a lot to walk out with. What did they say about your role?”
“Can you help me write back?”
- You
- “What do you want them to answer first?”
- Colleague
- “Whether I still own the draft.”
- You
- “How about opening with that? ‘Am I still the person you’d like to finish this draft?’”
End with their choice
Before you part, make any next step explicit. “Would you like me to read your draft tomorrow?” is clearer than assuming you’re now responsible for fixing the situation. If they’d rather leave it there, let that be enough.
Next time someone brings you a problem, try asking what kind of company they want in that moment. Listen to the answer, check again if the conversation changes, and let the person whose problem it is choose what happens next.